Civil-Military Relations
A comparative seminar on civilian control of the military, with cases on the US, Soviet Union, Latin America, Turkey, Pakistan, Japan and Africa.
How do civilians keep control of the people who hold the guns? This seminar starts with the texts of Lasswell, Huntington and Finer to clarify the basic tensions, then compares countries with stable civilian rule, stable military influence and swings between the two. Constitutional limits, parallel hierarchies, divide and rule and professionalism are among the mechanisms it weighs.
What You Will Achieve
- Identify the mechanisms civilians use to control a military
- Compare civilian control across at least two countries using the comparative method
- Present a country case in terms of which control mechanisms are present or absent
- Discuss how the military relates to wider society
Program Overview
General Issues
Three opening classes set out the tensions between the military and civilians.
- Lasswell, Huntington and Finer
- Civilian control mechanisms
Cases
Country studies show civilian control holding, failing and changing.
- The United States
- The Soviet Union, the Great Purge and the post-Soviet military
- Latin America, Turkey and Pakistan
- Japan and Africa
Military and Society
The closing classes widen the view beyond control of the armed forces.
- The military in multiethnic states
- The military and social change
Course Completion
Job Outlook
This comparative training is relevant to political science research and to policy analysis on defense and security.
Good for: Political science students and defense policy readers who want a comparative framework for judging how states control their armed forces.
Keep in mind: The class ran as a discussion seminar built around a 20-30 page research paper and oral presentations, so a self-guided reader gets the framework and the notes, not the debate.
Bottom line: A focused comparative seminar whose list of control mechanisms works as a checklist for studying any country’s armed forces.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which countries does the seminar study?
The cases are the United States, the Soviet Union, Latin America, Turkey and Pakistan, Japan and Africa, followed by classes on the military in multiethnic states and social change.
What was the main assignment?
A comparative research paper of 20-30 pages that compares civilian control mechanisms, or their absence, across at least two countries, along with an oral presentation on one case.
What control mechanisms are discussed?
They include constitutional and legal controls, parallel civilian hierarchies, divide and rule policies, a mass civilian army, a highly professionalized military, and centralizing or decentralizing command.



There are no reviews yet.