Moral Psychology
A philosophy seminar on human agency: free will and determinism, hierarchical selves, weakness of will, and whether disorders undermine blame.
Could our best science show that we have no genuine agency, and what would that do to blame and responsibility? This advanced philosophy seminar stays close to those questions, reading closely through debates over free will, then asking whether it makes sense to think of ourselves as selves that govern our own passions.
What You Will Achieve
- Reconstruct philosophical arguments clearly and charitably
- Assess positions on free will and determinism
- Evaluate hierarchical conceptions of the self
- Assess whether disorders of agency undermine responsibility
Program Overview
Free Will and Responsibility
The longest stretch of sessions moves through the classic positions.
- Skeptical, compatibilist and libertarian views
- Strawson’s and Bok’s two standpoints
- Holding ourselves and others responsible
Hierarchical Selves
The class then asks whether we really have ruling and ruled parts.
- Frankfurt’s psychological hierarchy
- Watson’s reply
- Science, metaphor or practical concept?
Weakness of Will and Disorders of Agency
Closing sessions test the theory on hard cases.
- Weakness of will
- Inverse akrasia
- Compulsion or choice
- Rescue or blame
Course Completion
Job Outlook
Careful reasoning about agency and responsibility is useful in academic philosophy, and in law, medicine and other fields that assign responsibility.
Good for: Philosophy students and readers ready for dense primary texts on free will, the self and responsibility.
Keep in mind: This spring 2024 version focuses on agency, so the description’s topics of evil and sympathy are not on its calendar. Readings and paper prompts only, no videos.
Bottom line: A focused seminar plan that takes one problem, human agency, and follows it a long way.
Frequently Asked Questions
How was the class graded?
Participation and three writing assignments each counted for 25%. Prompts came 10-14 days in advance, and own topics needed prior approval.
How should I approach the readings?
They are usually dense. The instructor recommends reading each selection twice before class and keeping it at hand for reference.
Could students use AI tools?
No. ChatGPT and similar tools were forbidden, because the instructor believes that learning to write clearly amounts to learning to think clearly.



There are no reviews yet.