Integrating Doctoral Seminar on Emerging Technologies
How decisions on new technology get made: uncertainty, politics and forecasting, with case studies on GPS, packet switching and supersonic transport.
How were decisions about GPS, the minicomputer or the supersonic transport actually made, and could they have been made better? This team-taught doctoral seminar studies emerging technologies at the meeting point of engineering, policy and society. It first builds a shared set of ideas about uncertainty and politics, then applies them through structured case presentations with experts.
What You Will Achieve
- Analyze a technology decision’s technical and political factors
- Weigh uncertainty and the limits of formal analysis
- Examine how forecasts of new technology have performed
- Propose improvements to a past decision process
Program Overview
Shared Ideas
Concepts for thinking about complex decisions.
- The power and limits of analysis
- Handling messy complexity
- The engineering mindset and the Columbia disaster
- Bureaucratic politics and technological forecasting
Case Presentations
Student teams with experienced experts.
- GPS for selected applications
- Packet switching for data communication
- The minicomputer and supersonic transport
- Seldane to Allegra and the National Airspace System
Final Paper
Drawing the threads together.
- Ubiquitous computing
- A final paper across all cases
Course Completion
Job Outlook
These skills are relevant to technology policy, doctoral research, research and development strategy and government analysis.
Good for: Doctoral students and technology policy analysts who want tested case frameworks for studying how technical decisions get made.
Keep in mind: It dates from 2005, so the cases stop there. The value came from discussion with people who took part in the decisions, which the slides and student papers can only partly convey.
Bottom line: A thoughtful case-based framework, useful mainly as a model for your own analysis.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a case presentation cover?
Background and timeline, the political or organizational context, the major decisions, uncertainties, basis of analysis, intended and unintended consequences, two or three themes, and how the process could improve.
What books are assigned?
Rescuing Prometheus by Thomas Hughes, and Essence of Decision by Graham Allison and Philip Zelikow on the Cuban Missile Crisis.
Are student papers included?
Yes. Responses to the readings and several 15 to 20 page final papers are published with the students' permission, and case presentations are in the lecture notes.



There are no reviews yet.